Living and Leading from Within
  • Home
  • About
  • NEW BOOK: The Rebel's Guide to Leadership
  • Programs & Retreats
  • The Circle of Trust® Approach
  • Event Calendar
  • Testimonials
  • Visual Quotes
  • Blog

Head versus Heart

9/2/2016

5 Comments

 
“A good head and a good heart
are always a formidable combination.”
                                                   - Nelson Mandela
Picture
In conversation with a colleague recently, I was dismayed to hear that we shouldn't use the word ‘heart’ when talking about leadership development.  Apparently ‘heart’ is frowned upon because it has subjective connotations which don’t sit well with the constant demand today for objective, measurable data.  Talk of the leader’s heart moves us into the realms of human feelings and intuition, both of which are clearly unmeasurable and, worse still, somewhat mysterious.  So this simply won’t do in today’s organisational environment which requires strong, objective, outcome-driven leadership.

As I said, I was dismayed - in fact I was disheartened - because I refer to ‘heart’ regularly when I'm talking about what we each bring to our work in the world – e.g. “the teacher’s heart” – “the leader’s heart”.  To me, ‘heart’ is so much more than simply the centre of our emotions and feelings.  When I refer to ‘heart’, I'm talking about the very core of our being, the place where we bring together our intellect, our knowledge and experience, our values and beliefs, and yes, also, our feelings and intuition.  When we’re able to operate from a place where all these parts of ourselves are integrated, feelings and intuition become an important source of creativity and wisdom.  From this integrated centre we are able to step back and separate from our ego, and recognise how ego loves to control our lives with fear, ambitions and desire.  Once freed from the controlling influence of the ego, we find we have the courage to show up in the world with all of ourselves, with our strengths and weaknesses, our successes and failures.  From this integrated centre we also can find a deeper sense of purpose in life and the courage to stand up and strive for what we believe in.

The domain of the heart is also where we develop our human capacity for making meaningful connections and building rich, respectful and trustworthy relationships with ourselves, with others and with our shared environment.

For me, the word ‘heart’ signifies the source of our personal integrity and it is central to our sense of humanity.
​
I believe the world needs more leaders with heart.
“The intuitive mind is a sacred gift
and the rational mind is a faithful servant.
We have created a society that honours the servant
and has forgotten the gift.” 
- Albert Einstein –
  

"The longest journey you will make in your life is from your head to your heart"
- Native American proverb -
5 Comments
Tom Ehlinger
9/2/2016 08:24:08 pm

Sorry you're hearing this about leadership. I've worked nearly 40 years as a lawyer in large corporations and one thing that has remained true through the entire time is that successful leaders (truly successful leaders and not just ones who get quick short term results and then are off somewhere else before the chickens come home to roost) are those who recognize that people work with their heads, but follow their hearts. And the leader's job is to hold a vision and create the narrative of that vision so that everyone can relate to it on a heart level. Heck, now that I'm old and don't care much what people think of me, I've even begun using the "L" word -- love. Love, and its place of residence, the heart are what powers life . Business leaders who don't understand that, will end up running sad and entropic organizations.

Reply
Kate Stagg
10/2/2016 01:41:20 am

I 'love' your response Tom. Personally, I would not have any desire to follow a leader who does not lead from their heart as well as their head.

Reply
Mennie Scapens
10/2/2016 10:39:53 am

Thanks for your response, Tom. I agree wholeheartedly. Yes, there are lots of leaders with heart out there, but sadly, I think there are many more whose ideas about leadership have grown in traditional hierarchical organisations, or in ego-driven outcome-focused organisations where success is measured purely in terms of the bottom-line and personal recognition. These can be soul-destroying places to work. I love the thought that you're game enough to use the "L" word. It speaks volumes to me about the life-giving nature of your workplace, and also of your personal approach. It also makes me smile, because I imagine it could raise a lot of eyebrows in many of the organisations I'm familiar with.

Reply
Kate Stagg
10/2/2016 01:49:43 am

A beautifully written reflection Mennie. You are a leader who openly leads from your heart, along with your rational mind. Those of us who have grown through your leadership would not have it any other way. It would be a sad world if our leaders were heartless (and perhaps therefore passionless). In today's world more than ever, we should be encouraging heart-ful leadership.

Reply
Mennie Scapens
10/2/2016 10:17:34 am

Thank you dear Kate. Open-hearted leaders grow open-hearted cultures - together we create workplaces that are a joy to be part of.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Categories

    All
    Attention
    Authenticity
    Authentic Leadership
    Awe
    Center For Courage & Renewal
    Change
    Christmas
    Connection
    Courage To Teach
    Education
    Ego
    Giving And Receiving
    Heart
    Integrity
    Leadership
    Listening
    Nature
    New Year
    Paradox
    Parker J. Palmer
    Poems
    Reflection
    Seasons
    Time
    Trust
    Wonder

    Mennie Scapens

    Mennie designs and leads leadership development programs, teacher renewal retreats, and programs for personal and professional development.  She is passionate about helping people uncover and grow their unique talents and dreams, and discovering personal pathways to living and leading authentic lives.  

    She is a facilitator prepared by the Center for Courage & Renewal. 

    Picture

    Archives

    April 2024
    January 2024
    November 2023
    March 2023
    December 2022
    May 2022
    October 2020
    June 2020
    December 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    October 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    February 2016
    September 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014

    RSS Feed


Mennie Scapens M.Ed
Courage & Renewal Facilitator
Phone +64 27 686 7449
Email  [email protected]


What participants have to say:

"Taking the time out of the busy rush of university life to really reconnect with my inner self was definitely invaluable! I had forgotten to really take a step back to re-evaluate my personal goals and see whether they align with my values."
   - Merit Scholar, Macquarie 
      University, Sydney, Australia.


​"Themes were explored using silence, interactive reflection, the most wonderful poems, videos and a variety of activities. I really appreciated learning about 'open and honest questions' which I now use in my practice as a clinical psychologist."
  -  Veerle Poels, Whakatane,
           NZ.


"A powerful, honest, and meaningful investment of time.  I came away with the understanding that deep self-reflection will yield better long-term results. 
Thank you for such a refreshing approach."

 - Participant, Auckland, NZ.